Nigar Afroz vs Mohd. Hasan on 12 July, 2023

Nigar Afroz vs Mohd. Hasan on 12 July, 2023


The case of Nigar Afroz vs Mohd. Hasan, heard in the Supreme Court of India, pertains to Transfer Petition (Criminal) Nos. 133-134 of 2021. The proceedings were presided over by Justices Aniruddha Bose and C.T. Ravikumar, focusing on a dispute that was ultimately resolved through a mutual settlement between the parties.


The dispute between Nigar Afroz and Mohd. Hasan was brought before the Supreme Court under Criminal Original Jurisdiction, seeking the transfer of criminal proceedings. As the case progressed, both parties reached a settlement agreement executed on April 19, 2023, which aimed to resolve the issues amicably and avoid further litigation.

Key Arguments:

The key argument in this case revolved around the petitioners’ request to transfer criminal proceedings to another jurisdiction. However, before the court could delve deeper into the merits of the case, the parties announced that they had reached a settlement, thus shifting the focus from legal arguments to the terms of the agreement.

Court’s Observations:

During the proceedings, the Court noted the submission of the settlement agreement by the counsel for both parties. The Justices acknowledged the mutual consent to the agreement and emphasized the importance of adhering to the obligations specified within it.

Court’s Decision:

Given the successful negotiation and execution of the settlement agreement, the Supreme Court found the petitions to be infructuous. As a result, the petitions and any associated pending applications were disposed of, concluding the legal proceedings between the parties without further contest.


The resolution of the case of Nigar Afroz vs Mohd. Hasan underscores the effectiveness of alternative dispute resolution in the judicial process. By settling their differences outside of court, the parties avoided prolonged litigation, highlighting how mutual agreements can lead to expedient and amicable resolutions in legal disputes. This case serves as a testament to the potential of settlements in simplifying and concluding complex legal matters efficiently.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *